Compliance Mi For Financial Advice Firms: What Should Managers Track? | BAT Software

BAT Software · Compliance insights

Compliance Mi For Financial Advice Firms: What Should Managers Track?

Charlie Palmer, CEO of IFA compliance platform BAT has a look back at some of the techniques used to satisfy the regulator today, and concludes that many need to look closely at the systems that they use to demonstrate compliance.

By Charlie Palmer, CEO of BAT Software
Management InformationConsumer DutyFCA compliance

You want to know where the retail financial services industry is heading, then look no further than the regulators. They control the direction as much as customers. In our heavily regulated sector, and the Financial Conduct Authority, the FCA, determine the direction of travel. In line with classic economic theory, the effect of regulation in the long term has largely been threefold. First of all standards will rise and have risen across the board. The weak, the part timers, those looking towards the finish and many of the chancers have left the industry to find easier pastures. That leaves the determined few, who can keep up with the one constant of regulation – change. So, secondly, those remaining put their prices up, to pay for the time spend on higher standards, and accelerate away creating ever more profitable companies. And the third impact - a cosy defensive moat of regulatory protection keeps the pesky competition away. Any established business would be crazy to complain about regulation.

I lived through the outrageous sell, sell, sell culture of the 1980’s and 1990’s. Things got bad, and some problems would not be unearthed until years later. One Allied Dunbar top salesman got enthusiastic about “MIPs”, those ten year investment plans that paid commission with most of the first two years of premiums. He routinely rebroked at year two, collected his awards at Allied Dunbar conferences and when the police came knocking on his door in Edinburgh, set up again in Dubai as a sales trainer. The endowment scandal, the first occupational pension transfer problems, and payment protection spring to mind, billions rechurned back to the clients, and the life offices barely exist compared to 30 years ago.

But what to make of the landscape today? The nadir may have been the Great Financial Crisis, GFC, in 2007-2009, but the regulatory minimum standards are multiple times higher than what was implemented in the immediate aftermath. The costs are exponentially higher. How I long for those days! When starting entrepreneurial businesses in financial services today, one is faced with something that could be mistaken for a protection racket. Put bluntly, you have to pay a lot of money to a lot of people to get the regulatory protection. And without that, you can’t trade. Flirting advice without a licence is a criminal offence, as many social media finfluencers have found out in court.

This article is about Compliance Management Information and with that background, you have a flavour of what is to come. Firstly the acronym MI - it is not about the compliance, per se, it is about showing compliance, and you do that through information. Show me the evidence your statement of compliance?

“I keep six honest serving-men (They taught me all I knew);

Their names are What and Why and When And How and Where and Who.”

You say that you have no complaints – how can you be so sure? Show me! We should be rename MI as SM. Management Information MI renamed Show Me SM. To put this into regulatory speak, and bring it up to date, I propose a statement of headings of what MI, (sorry SM!), I think all firms should be keeping, and how this is reflected in the BAT software... But before I do that, I want to explain why.

Why Keep The Data?

All firms will be faced with a day or reckoning. Not the Book of Revelations, but Due Diligence. This comes like a thief in the night. You apply for a provider agency, and they ask for due diligence questionnaire to be completed, and make their own checks. (all standard fayre in the mortgage world). But who prepares for this?

You sell your business, and buyers negotiate an offer, “subject to due diligence”. We have seen multiple companies approach BAT after failing due diligence. This usually concerns data integrity and the ability to provide reports instantly. Small IFAs typically fail to realise that when negotiating their exit the offer letter is just the start of the negotiations, not the end. The final decision is taken when due diligence is completed. You are not to know who finally makes the decision (you can ask, and you may be surprised by the answer). An offer, subject to due diligence, is barely worth the paper it is written on.

A problem emerges – your suppliers will require due diligence. Do not be surprised that the FCA ask suppliers for lists of firms that they have kicked off their panels. They want to see counterparty regulation in action. What’s not to like when the industry turns on itself and starts sanctioning weaklings in the supply chain?

FOS complaint emerges from your client bank, and notification goes to FCA of possible wider issues unearthed during your defence papers. Expect a due diligence audit. Random inspection? Retirement, change of control? If you add a director, and somehow the FCA ask for paper trail and find it lacking, you can expect a wider due diligence visit. You need data to support you.

A business of up to five, perhaps even up to ten people can cobble together statistics, reports, data and documents quite quickly. This leads to a false security. It is low cost, but on death or sudden exit where are the records? Typically each adviser submits CPD for their annual Statement of Professional Standing. Yes, you can allow them to self supervise, perhaps as co-directors, but what happens if they suddenly depart, and a back book review asks the remaining directors to prove the T&C records held. Are they held by firm or by individual? No. It does not stack up. Excel is not your friend. It is one dimensional, and not linked to documents. You must move from excel to systems, and the fast you do this, the easier your life will become later on. You can extract all the excel that you like from the systems later on, but systems first, excel second. This is about data entry, and that is where excel falls down. Good on export and display, bad on data entry. A single source of truth is the sine qua non of building a firm in the UK today.

Due diligence is lurking around the corner, and expects you to have a system. So go and get one, and centralise your control, adding and embedding value into your practice.

What Data To Keep?

  • Evidencing Good Outcomes Under the FCA Consumer Duty — This means moving from initial policy implementation to ongoing, data-backed board reporting and outcomes testing across advice, broking, and payment journeys.
  • AI Governance and Responsible Digital Adoption — Integrating automation into suitability checks is key. Checks on the automation with human oversight, explainability, and alignment with Consumer Duty.
  • Operational Resilience and Third-Party Oversight — Mitigating cyber threats and technology outages leads to outsourcing lists and risk dashboards.
  • Supporting Customers in Vulnerable Circumstances — Translating vulnerability into practical, consistent adjustments that you can show and demonstrate to third parties.
  • Financial Crime, Fraud, and Scam Prevention — Strengthening systems and controls against mortgage application fraud, money laundering source of funds and AI-enabled scams.
  • Fair Value Assessments and Fee Transparency — Justifying adviser charges, broker commissions, or payment fees across the distribution chain to prevent foreseeable financial harm.
  • Appointed Representatives (AR) and Network Governance — Tightening principal oversight, onboarding due diligence, and conflict-of-interest controls across intermediary networks and delegated authority models.
  • Data-Driven Compliance and Management Information (MI) — Replacing anecdotal reporting cobbled together when asked with granular customer-outcome metrics for FCA scrutiny.
  • Financial Promotions and Frictionless Digital Journeys — Ensuring online marketing is clear, fair, and not misleading while keeping policy renewal information clean.
  • Access, Inclusion, and Closing the Support Gap — Balancing efficiency with accessible human support so consumers are not excluded from essential mortgages, protection, investments, or payment services.

Across Mortgage Brokers, Independent Financial Advisers (IFAs), General Insurance GI brokers, and Payment Services firms, the FCA has moved away from siloed rule-based regulation in favour of principle based regulation. The Consumer Duty (Principle 12 and PRIN 2A) holds the ring. While each of these four subsectors operates under different rulebooks—the Mortgages and Home Finance: Conduct of Business sourcebook (MCOB), the Conduct of Business sourcebook (COBS), the Insurance: Conduct of Business sourcebook (ICOBS), and the Payment Services Regulations 2017 (PSRs)—all four share these principles, and retail customers are the same for all. The above list reads pretty much like a summary of FCA press releases over the last five years. Where is their focus going next is not for us to guess, and we are expected to have the above procedures and systems “embedded” to use an FCA term.

Evidencing Good Outcomes Under the FCA Consumer Duty

“TCF with bells on,” noted one sarcastic commentator on a forum. that Treating Customers Fairly TCF does not make the cut by itself. It may be 20 years old, but hasn’t gone away, although slightly subsumed by Consumer Duty. Some say Consumer Duty is TCF with The RDR-exempt SJP inside the new Venn diagram. You need a system to help here, and BAT has been designed to output data for due diligence.

The Consumer Duty has shifted compliance from demonstrating to proving, and like any good lawyer, you need evidence for that. You need evidence that your customers get consistently good outcomes. So now any sizeable firm has to embed this into routine “annual board attestation” (see financial exam in BAT for attestations as well as the auto-report writer).

Consumer Duty means you have to rate four core outcomes: products and services, price and value, consumer understanding, and consumer support. We have examples in the BAT document library. FCA expects boards to sign off on this and to drill down (an FCA term, not from ChatGPT) on management information (MI). After all that you then have to start writing up the remedials.

For mortgage brokers, evidencing good outcomes centres on product suitability. Why that repayment structure or term? And product transfer versus full remortgage recommendation. Might be easier for you, but what about the client?

IFAs face agonising justification for ongoing advice services and the demand for showing value rather than just collecting the tariff.

In general insurance broking, outcomes testing on the actual policies is key. Claims ratios and renewal stats must be available. Your compliance system needs to keep lists of exclusions, some evidence that they are actually understood. Like manufacturing, the focus is on the design. In payment services, firms must evidence some trouble free execution, transparency in forex pricing and show the FCA the account-freezing protocols.

Unlike in almost every other area where showing compliance trumps all else, in the payment services world the FCA want to see that your compliance does not leave the innocent without access to everyday funds. Even as I write this I wonder why these rules seem to apply to the smaller firms, but seem not to apply to giant banks who treat the innocent so badly, with widespread debanking for no good reason and with short notice, typically just two months.

AI Governance and Responsible Digital Adoption

AI is now core in workflows across IFA land and beyond into retail financial services. From December 2026 Claude will be offered as standard as part of 365 microsoft subscription and co-pilot. Claude data, unlike 365 data, goes to the USA and back, so added risk there if your staff use it. We all use generative AI for meeting transcription. Anyone can anonymise data before shoving it into a suitability report drafting AI. In mortgages algorithms are used for credit decisions. In insurance, algorithms help insurance underwriting, and payment fraud detection has seemingly moved into AI.

FCA sits atop the mountain pointing the finger of accountability at Senior Managers, who struggle to evaluate and compare tech for compliance. Those with fancy SMF titles setting up systems are now relabelled as “manager of human-in-the-loop verification protocol”.

FCA’s product neutral approach keep us all guessing, and makes counterparty regulation the biggest game in town. So that leads us back to due diligence! Maybe one day they’ll regulate the tech, like with open banking, and those firms, like BAT, will find the warm embrace of that regulatory moat!

General insurance brokers using automated quote-buy engines should audit for proxy discrimination (a new regulators buzz term) and to make sure that they remain compliant with equality legislation. Trump in the USA may have banned DEI policies, but in the UK they are mandatory.

You need a system to balance against these demands, and a system which keeps up with regulatory demands and standards, so that when the FCA ask for your pension transfer work to be broken down by type, limited or not, the new biz book categories can provide this.

Operational Resilience and Third-Party Oversight

IFAs, mortgage brokers, GI firms and PSD staff all depend on tightly controlled and automated supply chains. The FCA’s operational resilience framework (SYSC 15A) says that you must identify your Important Business Services. True to form the FCA have a term for this: IBS. And it is not a medical term.

So here you have to write out a risk mitigation programme, and state your tolerances. It is proportional, so may only take a few hours for a sole practitioner, but a week or so for a larger firm. Regulators want to see risk across your third-party providers assessed and mitigated.

Payment services firms sit at the sharp end here and they want to see Faster Payments connectivity, or other API in action. It is basically a software operation for you, cloud hosting, ledger providers, banking partnerships and pull throughs…all need to be graded, turned over and written up. You may need AI to write this up for you!

General insurance brokers face vulnerabilities around claims-handling platforms and delegated underwriting portals, particularly during surge events such as severe weather, where system latency directly delays emergency assistance for policyholders.

Mortgage brokers and IFAs fall outside enhanced operational resilience thresholds, but you remain fully bound by SYSC outsourcing rules and the Consumer Duty’s consumer support outcome. If your client CRM platform, investment wrap, or sourcing system suffers a prolonged cyber outage or ransomware incident, you are in theory responsible for maintaining client communication and pushing through time-sensitive instructions (expiring mortgage rates or portfolio switches in times of volatility.)

Business continuity plans are required by all. BAT system provides this, and you should check that any other system you run can also provide this.

Supporting Customers in Vulnerable Circumstances

FCA’s Guidance for firms on the fair treatment of vulnerable customers (FG21/1) indicates that nearly all of us are vulnerable at some stage. It is all in the language! But however you cut it up, you know there are four key drivers of vulnerability—health, life events, financial resilience, and financial capability. These need to be embedded into product design, training, and customer service workflows. However you do it, you need to ensure vulnerable consumers get the same experience as those of other clients, and be able to prove it.

In mortgage broking, vulnerability means relationship breakdown, bereavement, sudden income loss, or borrowers transitioning off historically low fixed rates onto higher repayment schedules. Look behind the calculators to anticipate foreseeable payment shock and signpost debt advice. Then find a way to demonstrate compliance.

For IFAs running investment portfolios, cognitive decline, dementia, and bereavement represent critical operational realities; firms need clear procedures for validating Powers of Attorney, spotting signs of undue influence from third parties, and adapting communication formats—such as larger print, visual cash-flow summaries, or follow-up confirmation calls—to support comprehension. Years ago I had a second visit with a large investor, who was elderly and worried about inheritance. On the second visit he asked me why I had brought a colleague along. “But I haven’t?” I replied, “Oh,” he spoke, “I am sorry, I have trouble with double vision.” I brought the meeting to a halt, and promised to come back the following week when his daughter would be there.

When I did so, I was astonished to find he had invested the money by himself with another local IFA – presumably one less squeamish about taking money from the vulnerable. Worse than double vision, he had confused the two of us.

GI brokers see vulnerability at the point of claim, when policyholders may be in distress following property damage, illness, or vehicle accidents. Rigid, script-driven claims handling may compound distress and breach Consumer Duty expectations. PSD firms have to deal with limited digital capability or checks on mental health, putting in gambling blocks or spending controls or some sort of double check.

On top of this all of us need to put in UK GDPR rules on special category data—recording vulnerability disclosures accurately with explicit consent.

Financial Crime, Fraud, and Scam Prevention

Financial crime is on the up, with state sponsored digital impacts. Authorised Push Payment (APP) fraud remains on top of the risk matrix as consumers fall for phishing emails. FCA have introduced mandatory APP fraud reimbursement - overseen by the Payment Systems Regulator (PSR).

Advisers must keep strict verification protocols before processing emailed withdrawal or bank-detail change requests. You can see that in your own office, and if you have someone else prepares or makes payments for you from your account, then double verification is essential, even when communicating constantly with someone perhaps inside the same office. At BAT we just tap out a teams or text message of confirmation – takes seconds, not minutes to do, and prevents someone external hijacking a message and changing the bank account numbers.

IFAs and wealth advisers represent prime targets for pension liberation scams, cloned investment websites, and impersonation fraud. Make doubly sure that you know who you are talking to, and keep a record of your rules. Mortgage brokers must application fraud – if you fail to spot it, don’t be surprised if it is you who are punished, and not the fraudster. Put bluntly, you’ll lose your agency, get chucked off panels, and get a visit from FCA. This includes undisclosed secondary borrowings and dodgy source-of-funds deposit payments, particularly if gifted, (as was revealed in the first Peter Mandelson scandal)

For GI brokers, application misrepresentation and claim queries require huge discipline with junior staff, often tempted quite naively to help clients construct their claims. We don’t want genuine policyholders to subsidise fraudsters making edgy claims after help from junior staff.

Systems operate to automate this sort of issue, and to provide management with the necessary reassurance.

Fair Value Assessments and Fee Transparency

Price and value is fair value. And in regulatory speak this all gets embedded into PRIN 2A.4. Another day, another rule, and this one requires firms to demonstrate a reasonable relationship between the total price paid and the overall benefits received. Of course it is a subjective judgement, but may help to alert all to what is often called “information asymmetry” – meaning when one party takes advantage of its knowledge to get one over the other party. The best example here is the PPI scandal. The first indication that something was wrong lay buried in the claims ratios. For PPI they were stuck in the 20% range. So just 20% of the income from premiums went back out again in claims, compared with the insurance industry average that is 50% to 60%.

FCA looks at fair value across the entire distribution chain rather than in isolation. So that means you should do the same, and have systems to show it.

Retailers all must conduct formal Fair Value Assessments (FVAs). IFAs, GI brokers, mortgage brokers, PSD firms, all should share relevant information across the chain, and ensure cumulative costs don’t outweigh customer benefits. You’ve done it already, but you’re going to have to review regularly, and then go and explain it over email, with reports or face to face. How can you do this without a system to work with?

If you think that it’s a damned cheek to have to justify ourselves in front of anyone other than our customer, then you’re in the wrong business, or living in the wrong country – even bookmakers can’t do that anymore. IFAs need to justify their AMC, and Mortgage brokers the fees added to the loan, GI firms over-ride commission, and PSD firms the hidden forex charge.

Appointed Representatives (AR) and Network Governance

The Appointed Representative (AR) regime is the easy way to get a licence with the FCA. And so long as you follow their rules, then you should be safe to operate under their regulatory umbrella.

The FCA hate this regime, of course, as it concentrates risk and is seen as an easy route to avoid the FCA spotlight. Following high-profile supervisory interventions the FCA holds principal firms strictly accountable and the standards are as a result typically higher inside the franchise than out of it. The key reason for this, of course, is that systems and procedures are mandated, using systems like BAT, so no more cobbling things together, firms have to enter business centrally onto a single CRM and follow mandates.

Onboarding due diligence requires verification that prospective ARs possess genuine business acumen, with a proper business plan, hold professional indemnity PI cover, and have clean regulatory histories. Central to that is the reference. Without a clean reference, firms and individuals are stranded. It is counter party regulation all over again. BAT designed an entire suite here, called SM&CR to handle the multiple steps required to onboard a director, AR or RI, from references and tests to CVs and bank account statements. It is easy enough to tick a box at FCA to say “I’ve done my due diligence” but heaven help you if the FCA ask for evidence and you’re creating it after the event, and get caught out trying to say that you did this beforehand. That’s effectively fraud, and it is not uncommon.

Once onboarded, advisers cannot rely on annual self-attestation questionnaires; they must deliver up file reviews, and undergo annual audits, as a minimum to verify that ARs stay within guardrails.

Data-Driven Compliance and Management Information (MI)

Traditional compliance reporting is obsolete. Two tone internal metrics such as the percentage of suitability files passing internal checklist audits or completion rates for annual e-learning modules is all well and good, but the FCA has repeatedly emphasised that high file-pass rates mean little if customer outcome data tells a contradictory story.

You have to get more MI out of the system to deliver up patterns to predict harm (or good outcomes). A forward looking risk approach requires top quality compliance systems. AI is your friend here, and most systems, including BAT allows for export of excel into Claude (best) or other Ai tools, to then start predicting direction of travel.

For IFAs and mortgage brokers, this MI is tracking persistency rates, early mortgage redemptions, laps ratios, NPW’s, complaint root-cause, Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) uphold rates, and numbers of clients paying ongoing fees without recorded annual reviews. General insurance brokers must monitor premiums written, claims repudiation rates, mid-term cancellations, renewal price-walking, and customer satisfaction surveys. In payment services firms, data-driven compliance relies on real-time operational telemetry: failed payment rates, chargeback resolution times, account-freezes, complaints and help requests.

MI should link to risk-appetite thresholds and governance interventions need to be shown. You need a system to do this, and BAT is your friend.

Financial Promotions

Social media has transformed how retail financial products are marketed and purchased, bringing intense regulatory focus onto social media promotions, online user-interface design, and post-sale customer support. Under the financial promotions regime, firms must ensure all marketing communications are fair, clear, and not misleading. They must also ensure that all promotions are signed off or approved by senior management prior to exposure. How to do that with social media?

The answer is that it is hard, and as a result, only a minority, a tiny number, of firms do social media promotions that involve entering into chat or live promotions.

BAT has a system for checking all promotions, with real-time approvals provided by our compliance partners, including IFAC. This tool has consistently surpassed expectations, as it enables a register of approvals, failures, time to upload and so on metrics to churn out, valuable filler for those pesky consumer duty reports. It is quite unique, and stands aloft of all competitors.

Access, Inclusion, and Closing the Support Gap

Across the UK, millions of consumers fall into the "advice gap"—possessing modest savings or straightforward financial needs that make expensive IFA or broker holistic advice unaffordable. But they still require reliable guidance to navigate mortgages, protection, retirement, and everyday payments safely.

How does the regulator square that one? The answer is that they don’t. If you choose to focus only on those who can afford your prices, then that is your prerogative. You can choose that route, but you still can’t just chuck the rule book in the bin. Au contraire, you need to keep a record of those who you will not deal with, and use that in your consumer duty report, to show how you are shaping your business to target some customers, but not all. And only then can you close the book of compliance, and go home.

If I was you, I’d get a system that does all this for you. And with that, I rest my case. BAT is the only compliance first platform on the market for IFAs and mortgage brokers.

Share this update